Northern Europe scoops the pool for pension systems

David Knox

The Netherlands, Switzerland and Sweden were ranked the top three countries for their pension systems in the second annual study which rated adequacy, sustainability and integrity of both public and private pensions around the world.

The study, by consulting firm Mercer and the Australian Centre for Financial Services, an educational body, included 14 countries (11 last year), with Switzerland, Brazil and France added to the latest list.

Switzerland took Australia’s previous number-two spot, but the relative rating of Sweden as well pushed Australia into number four, ahead of Canada.

Australia has the fastest growing accumulation of pension assets in the world because of its compulsory 9 per cent of wages and salaries going into superannuation funds. This growth is expected to accelerate in the next few years because the recently re-elected Australian Labor Government has pledged to increase the compulsory saving to 12 per cent over time.

Mercer said Australia fell not only because of Switzerland’s inclusion but also because of new indicators relating to the cost of its retirement system. The report noted that the recent Australian Government review of its system also identified costs as an area which needed addressing.

The study is based on more than 40 indicators which reflect features that are desirable in retirement savings and income systems.

Sponsored Content

David Knox, a senior partner in Mercer’s Retirement, Risk and Finance practice, said the global financial crisis had threatened the sustainability of public and private pension systems in several countries through the decline in asset values and an increase in debt. Most acutely, this was reflected in Canada, the UK and US.

Overall rankings, with previous year in parentheses, were:

1.     Netherlands (1)

2.    Switzerland (-)

3.    Sweden (3)

4.    Australia (2)

5.    Canada (4)

6.    UK (5)

7.    Chile (7)

8.    Brazil (-)

9.    Singapore (8)

10.  USA (6)

11.    France (-)

12.   Germany (9)

13.  Japan (11)

14.  China (10)

Leave a Comment

Sort content by

The cost of bad asset allocation

A study of 300 US pension funds by CEM Benchmarking reinforces the importance of asset allocation, highlighting the performance of asset classes, as well as new evidence on correlations between asset classes. Alex Beath, author of the study, discusses the implications for asset allocation with Amanda White. A CEM Benchmarking study “Asset Allocation and Fund

The OECD’s plan for long-term investment

G20 financial ministers and central bank governors welcomed the findings of the G20/OECD roundtable on institutional investors and long-term investment last month, which included clear plans to incentivise institutional investors to undertake more long-term investments. The roundtable, “From solutions to actions: implementing measures to encourage institutional long-term investment financing”, held in Singapore recognised that long-term

Why long-horizon investors should adopt factor-based asset allocation

Long-horizon investors can withstand macro-economic volatility and so should tilt towards strategies that are exposed to that, including value, small cap and momentum. Oleg Ruban, vice president in the applied research team at MSCI says this validates factor-investing and factor-based asset allocation for these investors.   Appropriate asset allocation requires explicit attention be paid to

The case for long-termism

Keith Ambachtsheer’s lead article in the Fall 2014 edition of the Rotman International Journal of Pension Management, takes readers through an historical and logical journey that supports the case for long-termism. Importantly he validates this with four high-profile investor case studies which demonstrate that a long-term view benefits society but also the investors, willing to

Investors alter allocations because of climate risks

A number of large institutional investors, including AP1, the Environment Agency and AustralianSuper, made changes to their strategic asset allocation as a result of Mercer’s 2011 study on climate risks, and now the consultant is working with a new raft of investors to assess forward-looking climate change scenarios against their current allocations. Meanwhile one of

Real estate sector continues to lead on sustainability: GRESB

This year’s Global Real Estate Sustainability Benchmark (GRESB) reveals that sustainability reporting has improved in coverage and quality of data, with the average overall score increasing due to increasing implementation and measurement. The average score is now 47 (out of 100) which is up nine points this year. The benchmark collects data from 637 listed

Previous