Northern Europe scoops the pool for pension systems

David Knox

The Netherlands, Switzerland and Sweden were ranked the top three countries for their pension systems in the second annual study which rated adequacy, sustainability and integrity of both public and private pensions around the world.

The study, by consulting firm Mercer and the Australian Centre for Financial Services, an educational body, included 14 countries (11 last year), with Switzerland, Brazil and France added to the latest list.

Switzerland took Australia’s previous number-two spot, but the relative rating of Sweden as well pushed Australia into number four, ahead of Canada.

Australia has the fastest growing accumulation of pension assets in the world because of its compulsory 9 per cent of wages and salaries going into superannuation funds. This growth is expected to accelerate in the next few years because the recently re-elected Australian Labor Government has pledged to increase the compulsory saving to 12 per cent over time.

Mercer said Australia fell not only because of Switzerland’s inclusion but also because of new indicators relating to the cost of its retirement system. The report noted that the recent Australian Government review of its system also identified costs as an area which needed addressing.

The study is based on more than 40 indicators which reflect features that are desirable in retirement savings and income systems.

Sponsored Content

David Knox, a senior partner in Mercer’s Retirement, Risk and Finance practice, said the global financial crisis had threatened the sustainability of public and private pension systems in several countries through the decline in asset values and an increase in debt. Most acutely, this was reflected in Canada, the UK and US.

Overall rankings, with previous year in parentheses, were:

1.     Netherlands (1)

2.    Switzerland (-)

3.    Sweden (3)

4.    Australia (2)

5.    Canada (4)

6.    UK (5)

7.    Chile (7)

8.    Brazil (-)

9.    Singapore (8)

10.  USA (6)

11.    France (-)

12.   Germany (9)

13.  Japan (11)

14.  China (10)

Leave a Comment

Sort content by

Why integrated reporting makes sense: Robert Eccles

Robert Eccles has been trying to change the nature of corporate reporting for more than 20 years. He has been an advocate for supplementing financials with information on non-financial factors that are leading indicators of financial results – such as product development, customer satisfaction and the development of intangible assets. The premise is those companies

Opportunities in Europe

Investors and academics agree that political developments in Greece are important because they may shape how financial markets will respond to future political situations in the Eurozone. But according to Olivier Rousseau, the executive director of the FFR, the French pension reserve fund, there is more hype outside of the Eurozone on the implications of

More evidence big is better in pension funds

A pension fund that has 10 times more assets under management has on average 7.67 basis points lower annual investment costs according to a working paper from authors at De Nederlansche Bank, that explores the relationship between pension fund size and investment costs. Written by Dirk Broeders, Arco van Oord and David Rijsbergen the paper

European investment plan requires public private collaboration

The two largest institutional investors in the Netherlands, PGGM and APG, have responded to the European Commission’s investment plan, urging the commission to call on institutional investors to collaborate on the investment proposal. However they also warn that institutional investors are not just a “subsidising entity” and the Juncker Plan is best executed as a

Why Andrew Ang joined Blackrock

Andrew Ang believes factor investing is a more efficient way to organise a portfolio as it allows liquid and illiquid strategies to be managed across the portfolio. It also has the added benefit of honing managers on value creation. He’s been working with a handful of investors while Professor of Finance at Columbia University on

The power of engagement

It is called the “CalPERS’ Effect” but it could easily be called the asset owner effect, or the institutional investor effect, or the power of engagement effect. Wilshire, which is a consultant to the $300 billion Californian fund CalPERS, has provided an update on its study measuring the effect of engagement on a targeted list of companies called the Focus List.

Previous