How NBIM spots portfolio managers’ biases using AI

Norges Bank Investment Management (NBIM) is using an internally developed engine powered by AI to monitor and measure its portfolio managers’ skills, aiming to identify behavioural biases, improve decision making, efficiency of trades and save costs.

The system, called the Investment Simulator, currently covers all internal active portfolio managers in NBIM’s sector strategies as well as external fund managers of the $1.8 trillion investor. The result is information that helps them reflect on their trading patterns and identify strengths and weaknesses, according to NBIM head of Singapore and co-head of equity trading Sumer Dewan.

As the world’s largest investor, the fund makes around 49 million transactions per year, trading around the clock with its Singapore, Oslo, London, and New York offices’ coverage.

NBIM started expanding the tool’s usage in equity trading as a part of its three-year company plan which began in 2023. It stated at the time that the goal is to “promote psychological safety so that our portfolio managers dare to be contrarian and avoid herd behaviour”.

The tool provides a behavioural score of stock pickers based on historical order records. While Dewan declined to identify specific factors the scorecard tracks, one basic example is whether a portfolio manager holds onto their losing companies for too long, or their winners for too short.

Eventually, the fund wants the tool to become “agentic”, giving more real-time feedback and suggestions, instead of just after-the-fact.

Sponsored Content

“[The Investment Simulator] will be there soon… the speed at which this can be made [happen] is just incredible,” Dewan tells Top1000funds in an interview.

“Even where I sit, when a new trade comes in, I see who has sent it – let’s get a behavioural analysis of them.

“[It can also] tell me everything I need to know about this company very quickly, discuss current market conditions, and make recommendations of the best way to transact.”

There is also another version of the scorecard for NBIM’s traders and index portfolio managers, who have shorter trading time horizons compared to portfolio managers in sector strategies.

“But both scorecards are multidimensional in nature – timing, sizing, positioning, trading around and responding to events,” Dewan said.

“Traders also have tremendous discretion about how they trade so there are lots of variables we can look into.”

AI integration fund-wide

NBIM is well-advanced in its integration of AI in investment processes. The fund’s chief executive, ex-hedge fund manager Nicolai Tangen, is leading from the top with a clear message that using AI is not an option, but a must.

The fund has “AI ambassadors” scattered in different offices who Dewan says are volunteers spreading knowledge about the technology and helping people “unlock the door”. Departments and investment units in the firm are also encouraged to conduct their own AI projects with the ambassadors’ help.

Claude, a family of AI models and assistant developed by US firm Anthropic, is the main AI tool at NBIM, with the chatbot integrated across all devices in the organisation.

Dewan says that through the help of the internal ambassadors, he has transformed how he uses the tools and the information they provide, with tailored reporting and enhanced project management including recommendations.

There is the obvious cost-saving benefit of AI, too. For example, the technology can reduce unnecessarily trades by predicting future orders and opportunities to transact internally.

As the world’s largest sovereign wealth fund with 71.4 per cent of its AUM invested in equities, NBIM has a significant passive exposure and hence the need for constant rebalancing.

Tangen previously touted that the AI tool is already shaving $100 million off the fund’s trading costs every year and the ultimate target is to save $400 million, but Dewan says he “wouldn’t be surprised if we went beyond that number”.

“[With] the size of the fund and the holdings, there is a significant amount of internal crossing… that can be done – that itself is cost free,” he says.

“So right then and there, you are able to – by bringing your left and right hand talking together – fully analyse, anticipate and predict how your inventory looks and how it will look.”

These tools are still a “work-in-progress” but being able to test their effectiveness in a risk-controlled environment helps.

“We don’t just think our way forward, we build our way forward. We prototype, and that is very much in the DNA of the firm,” Dewan said.

Leave a Comment

How CPP is evolving risk management for a faster, more interconnected world

How CPP is evolving risk management for a faster, more interconnected world

In an environment where multiple risks are emerging and their effects are compounding on the portfolio, CPP Investments' chief risk officer Priti Singh says the $572 billion fund is rethinking risk management from the ground up, shifting from reaction to preparation and embedding risk thinking earlier in investment decisions. She speaks to Amanda White about the fund's risk approach.

Sort content by

BCI: A masterclass in private debt

British Columbia Investment Management Corporation has been investing in private debt since 2018. Global head of public markets Daniel Garant, whose team oversees private debt, articulates the secrets of success at a time of fierce competition for returns as more investors pile into the asset class, tightening credit spreads.

A rock and a hard place: GEPF on the challenges of transitioning coal

Reducing exposure to the risk in coal is particularly challenging for South Africa’s $122 billion Government Employees Pension Fund. ESG manager Belaina Negash explains the complexities due to the industry's tie with the economy and the fund's transition framework.

Mid-market, asset-backed private credit shines for growing Asian allocators

Asia's growing investors, including university endowments and family offices, are hunting for returns in lower-middle market and asset-backed private credit. In an interview with Top1000funds.com, head of Asian clients at the $92 billion OCIO Cambridge Associates, Prabhat Ojha, talks manager selection and Asian allocators' rising appetite for alternatives.

France’s FRR ups risk in line with longer term investment horizon

Fonds de reserve pour les retraites (FRR), France’s €21 billion ($24 billion) pension reserve fund, has increased its weighting to equity in line with a new strategic asset allocation to reflect the investor's longer return horizon. It is also eyeing more unlisted assets including private equity, private debt and infrastructure.

AP4: Why a dynamic, shorter term allocation is paying off

Volatile markets have provided a rich hunting ground and opportunistic best ideas have come thick and fast for AP4’s new five-pronged global allocation made up of systematic equity, currency and rates, asset allocation, hedge funds/external mandates and analysis. Magdalena Högberg explains the risks and opportunities of the best ideas allocation.

University of California: Less is more and simple is better in investing

Jagdeep Singh Bachher, the CIO who oversees the University of California's $198 billion in pension and endowment assets, says that he wants to keep investment simple as the fund removed its hedge fund allocation completely, conceding "it’s not one of the things we are good at doing".

Previous