How NBIM spots portfolio managers’ biases using AI

Norges Bank Investment Management (NBIM) is using an internally developed engine powered by AI to monitor and measure its portfolio managers’ skills, aiming to identify behavioural biases, improve decision making, efficiency of trades and save costs.

The system, called the Investment Simulator, currently covers all internal active portfolio managers in NBIM’s sector strategies as well as external fund managers of the $1.8 trillion investor. The result is information that helps them reflect on their trading patterns and identify strengths and weaknesses, according to NBIM head of Singapore and co-head of equity trading Sumer Dewan.

As the world’s largest investor, the fund makes around 49 million transactions per year, trading around the clock with its Singapore, Oslo, London, and New York offices’ coverage.

NBIM started expanding the tool’s usage in equity trading as a part of its three-year company plan which began in 2023. It stated at the time that the goal is to “promote psychological safety so that our portfolio managers dare to be contrarian and avoid herd behaviour”.

The tool provides a behavioural score of stock pickers based on historical order records. While Dewan declined to identify specific factors the scorecard tracks, one basic example is whether a portfolio manager holds onto their losing companies for too long, or their winners for too short.

Eventually, the fund wants the tool to become “agentic”, giving more real-time feedback and suggestions, instead of just after-the-fact.

Sponsored Content

“[The Investment Simulator] will be there soon… the speed at which this can be made [happen] is just incredible,” Dewan tells Top1000funds in an interview.

“Even where I sit, when a new trade comes in, I see who has sent it – let’s get a behavioural analysis of them.

“[It can also] tell me everything I need to know about this company very quickly, discuss current market conditions, and make recommendations of the best way to transact.”

There is also another version of the scorecard for NBIM’s traders and index portfolio managers, who have shorter trading time horizons compared to portfolio managers in sector strategies.

“But both scorecards are multidimensional in nature – timing, sizing, positioning, trading around and responding to events,” Dewan said.

“Traders also have tremendous discretion about how they trade so there are lots of variables we can look into.”

AI integration fund-wide

NBIM is well-advanced in its integration of AI in investment processes. The fund’s chief executive, ex-hedge fund manager Nicolai Tangen, is leading from the top with a clear message that using AI is not an option, but a must.

The fund has “AI ambassadors” scattered in different offices who Dewan says are volunteers spreading knowledge about the technology and helping people “unlock the door”. Departments and investment units in the firm are also encouraged to conduct their own AI projects with the ambassadors’ help.

Claude, a family of AI models and assistant developed by US firm Anthropic, is the main AI tool at NBIM, with the chatbot integrated across all devices in the organisation.

Dewan says that through the help of the internal ambassadors, he has transformed how he uses the tools and the information they provide, with tailored reporting and enhanced project management including recommendations.

There is the obvious cost-saving benefit of AI, too. For example, the technology can reduce unnecessarily trades by predicting future orders and opportunities to transact internally.

As the world’s largest sovereign wealth fund with 71.4 per cent of its AUM invested in equities, NBIM has a significant passive exposure and hence the need for constant rebalancing.

Tangen previously touted that the AI tool is already shaving $100 million off the fund’s trading costs every year and the ultimate target is to save $400 million, but Dewan says he “wouldn’t be surprised if we went beyond that number”.

“[With] the size of the fund and the holdings, there is a significant amount of internal crossing… that can be done – that itself is cost free,” he says.

“So right then and there, you are able to – by bringing your left and right hand talking together – fully analyse, anticipate and predict how your inventory looks and how it will look.”

These tools are still a “work-in-progress” but being able to test their effectiveness in a risk-controlled environment helps.

“We don’t just think our way forward, we build our way forward. We prototype, and that is very much in the DNA of the firm,” Dewan said.

Leave a Comment

PGGM: Impact begins at home

PGGM: Impact begins at home

PGGM is preparing to build out the third element to its impact strategy targeting biodiversity. By focusing on food and the circular economy, PGGM aims to create most impact at home. Top1000funds.com looks at the fund's impact journey.

Sort content by

CalPERS’ new asset allocation to take on more risk

The largest pension fund in the United States, the $469 billion CalPERS, is in the middle of an asset liability modelling exercise to set a new asset allocation by June 2022. Chief executive Marcie Frost says it’s the most significant decision the board makes with regard to the investment portfolio and that achieving a return target of 6.8 per will require “pushing everyone’s risk appetite”.

CalPERS reduces equities universe

In the first story of an exclusive series examining investment portfolio innovation at CalPERS, Amanda White looks at the global equities portfolio where the universe of stocks was recently halved.

APG positions for a digital future

APG, the biggest pension provider in Europe, is positioning itself as a digital pioneer with investment in the large-scale use of data, workflow automation and digital analytical platforms. A leader in funds management, most notably sustainability, it is once again a frontrunner by embracing technology.

Indiana’s new asset allocation

Indiana PRS’ five-year asset liability study has resulted in a newly approved target rate of return that CIO Scott Davis dubs one of the most realistic in the country, and a radically different asset allocation. Next on the agenda is a research project examining the fund’s sources of alpha which could have big implications for how it works with managers.

Florida SBA’s venture adventure

The Florida State Board of Administration’s (SBA) commitment to venture capital over many decades has been a contributor to the fund's performance. Last year the team had 340 meetings and calls, reviewed 109 funds, carried out due diligence on 26 and invested in three. Successful IPOs and SPACs, plus realisations from investments made in 2013/14, have led to a standout performance.

Finding alpha: Church Commissioners outperform

The £9.2 billion portfolio managed for the Church Commissioners for England has returned 9.7 per cent over 10 years through a focus on sustainability and a willingness to try things early, such as forestry and venture capital. Amanda White spoke to CIO Tom Joy about where the fund looks for alpha and the need for a non-traditional allocation.

Previous