Illinois pension reform

At least one state in the US is acting on the need for epic reform of its pension system, but the political difficulty associated with such reform – something all states are wary of – was demonstrated in the violent outburst by Illinois representative, Mike Bost, last week (see video) and the inability of representatives to agree to the reform package before the state assembly broke last week for summer.

Pension reform is the reform of our lifetime, according to Illinois governor, Pat Quinn, who is determined to fundamentally change the system.

“We must enact bold reform that eliminates the unfunded liability,” he says.

The state is facing $83 billion in unfunded liabilities and Quinn is worried about ratings-agency suggestions they will lower the state’s credit rating if the state assembly doesn’t take action.

The reform agenda includes increasing employer contributions so the funding ratio will reach 100 per cent in 2042. It also proposes that members increase their retirement age to 67.

Sponsored Content

The eruption of Mike Bost in the Springfield assembly last week is indicative of the frustration that policy makers, fund trustees and staff are experiencing with regard to the dire pension situation in the US.

Bost, who reacted strongly to the amount of time he had to discuss a pension-policy reform agenda, launched into a soliloquy about the adverse control of the state speaker and the inability to effect reform.

“I feel like someone escaping from Egypt: let my people go,” he yelled in the assembly last week. “I’m trapped by the rules being forced down my throat. We live in a democracy, but not here. The speaker has too much control.”

A few days after his outburst, the Illinois House of Representatives broke for the summer but pension reform was not passed due to disagreement on a provision to shift the pension costs from state to local school districts.

Now the governor is calling for a special legislative session in the summer to deal with the reform.

“We are racing the clock,” he said.

The Illinois State Board of Investments manages the $11.5 billion in assets of the pension funds and has a fairly aggressive allocation: US equities 30 per cent, international equities 20 per cent, fixed income and cash 20 per cent, private equity 5 per cent, real estate 10 per cent, infrastructure 5 per cent, hedge funds 10 per cent.

While the state politicians could not agree on the “reform of our lifetime”, they did pass a law called the “skin tax”, which will charge strip-club patrons $3 each – the money going to sexual-assault-prevention services.

Who would be a politician?

2 responses to “Illinois pension reform”

  1. Leo de Bever

    Fair enough: contribution holidays were not a smart idea.
    But if liabilities are compounding at 8.5 percent, does that not suggest contribution rates were too low to start with.
    You can only earn 8.5 percent if you put 100 percent in equity like instruments

  2. Jim Philip

    Let’s be clear the current pension problem has little to nothing to do with benefits it is instead caused by decades of governors and lawmakers from both political parties who have chosen to spend available revenues on other state programs rather than sock enough away to pay for the pension benefits workers were earning. The dollars not put into the retirement kitty in turn did not earn any return on investment or compound over the years, so the gap has grown ever increasingly larger.

    The partial pension payment holidays (SB 27) taken in FY 2006 and FY 2007 is only one example of how dramatically not contributing the required state contributions can lead to increasing the state’s unfunded liability in this case by $7.1 billion in only three years. During that period, no retirement benefits were increased but because interest on the unfunded liability compounds at between 8.0% and 8.5%, any payment shortfall, such as the pension holiday, quickly increases the unfunded liability.
    “The deadly combination of nearly 30 years of systematic state underfunding of its employer contributions to the pension systems, followed by the cataclysmic decline in asset values caused by the national meltdown in financial markets over the last year, has combined to create an all-time high in the state’s unfunded pension liability,”
    To know how to fix the problem we must first know what caused the problem. The problem has been caused by drastic underfunding of all state pensions except one, IMRF which, wait for it, has a mandatory funding provision.
    The answer lies in 1. Re-setting the actuarial clock to 100% funded in 40 years using sound actuarial assumptions of level payments. 2. Mandatory funding like the IMRF pension fund enjoys. 3. Negotiate with labor to participate in some reduction in benefits and or increases in employee contributions. The road will be rough for all but it is obtainable if all parties will look at what the problem is and then how to fix it.

Leave a Comment

More from this fund

Sort content by

Big Bond Bust

In his editorial in the latest edition of the FAJ, Richard Ennis calls into question the role of advanced, aggressive fixed-income strategies, questioning the suitability of such techniques in the part of the investor’s portfolio that bears the brunt of providing downside protection.mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

CalPERS on path to improving risk intelligence

The CalPERS governance risk management initiative (GRMI) project team, led by Allen Goldstein of The Results Group, has reported to the board on phase II of the project, concluding with 17 preliminary observations of areas of improvement. mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

DNB approves Shell recovery plan

The 10.6 billion ($15 billion) Shell Pension Fund’s recovery plan has been approved by De Nederlandsche Bank and includes a provision to increase employer contributions to 32 per cent, up from 5 per cent last year, on the back of a whopping -43.3 per cent return for 2008. mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

TRS invests in PE, eyes opportunistic real estate

The $30 billion Teachers’ Retirement System of the State of Illinois (TRS) will commit up to $1.2 billion to private equity, and will focus on opportunistic investments in real estate including emerging manager initiatives, as it aims to reach its new long-term allocations in those sectors by year end. mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

Canadian funds delve into performance drivers

Four of Canada’s pension funds have established a professorship in pension management at the Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto with initial research to focus on a better understanding of the drivers of pension fund performance using the global databases of CEM Benchmarking. mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

Counterparty risk prompts changes in sec lending

More than two thirds of the institutions that made changes to their securities lending programmes on the back of the global financial crisis cited less confidence in counterparty stability as the driver, research has revealed, however less than 20 per cent suspended participation following the market volatility. mrec4inarticleinline Sponsored Content scnative1 scnative2 scnative3

Previous