IN CONVERSATION

On a mission to cure capitalism

When pension funds are evaluating what to invest in, start asking questions, it will have a profound effect." Al Gore

Al Gore, former US vice president and co-founder with investment banker David Blood, of Generation Investment Management, said sustainable capitalism is not an argument that pension funds should sacrifice value in return for values.

Rather it is consistent with the core fiduciary relationship to match liabilities.

“It’s what it’s all about,” he says.

Gore defends capitalism, saying it is at the base of every successful economy: it efficiently allocates resources, it is congruent with freedom, and importantly it is the one system that unlocks the future of individuals with incentives that unlock ingenuity. However, he is despondent at how capitalism is being pursued.

“No wonder with those virtues that everything’s going great in the world’s economy,” he says ironically. “If capitalism has all these strengths and is hegemonic in organising economic activities, why do we have these problems?”

“In the US for sure a public pension crisis is pending, California, Rhode Island, go right down the list. The conspiracy of the present against the future is bigger than I imagined,” he says. “If we are trying to predict into the future such a narrow slice of information we ignore the possibility of ruining civilisation as we know it, there’s something wrong with the way we’re pursuing capitalism.”

He notes the distribution of income is not measured, and rising inequality is not measured in the assessment of the economy.

“We’ve made our choice for capitalism – now the focus is on how we pursue capitalism. The concept of sustainable capitalism is not an argument that pension funds should sacrifice value in return for values. Rather they should start from a premise that it should be best practice because you’ll get better returns over time.”

He says a wider scope of information assessment and processing is crucial to sustainable capitalism.

“As vice president in the White House for eight years, every morning for an hour I got a review of the military information, from many sources. What we see with our eyes is not all that is there, we can organise ourselves to include more information,” he says. “We are used to focusing on quarterly reports, number metrics are all important but only a narrow source of the value spectrum. If companies ignore the people associated with their supply chains or environmental impact then there is brand damage, that information is directly relevant to the value of the equity assessment.”

(As an aside Apple Inc, of which Gore is a long-time board member recently hired former head of the US Environmental Protection Agency, Lisa Jackson to head up its environmental effort.)

Gore believes there is a governance crisis in the world today.

“Democracy having become accepted as the best form of government has been failing to meet the test of leadership required in 21st century,” he says.

“The US has been the de facto leader but in the last decade the quality of US governance led to a crisis of confidence in the US leadership. The world is relatively rudderless.”

Specifically, he says that US public pension funds have taken some immense risks by allocating large percentages of their portfolios to high risk assets, because governance structures reward them for doing so.

It is within investors’ power to change this.

Gore’s partner at Generation Investment Management, David Blood, says long-term asset owners have a critical role to play, and must first assess what is in their best interests.

“What will they support to realise more value?” he asks. “It is a challenge to get them together and get them to listen. Investors are uncomfortable in the conversation around sustainability. What has frustrated us is we always thought it gets a better sense of the company.”

Gore quotes the psychologist, Abraham Maslow who says if the only tool you have is a hammer then every problem looks like a nail.

“The same is true if the only thing you use to assess a company is a price tag.”

In its seminal paper, Sustainable Capitalism, Generation outlined mandated integrated reporting as one of five recommendations to move towards sustainable capitalism.

“Financial statements are one perspective in the value of the business. You need to look at the sources of capital – physical, intellectual, and social capital – and only one of those is on the balance sheet,” he says. “Other forms of capital don’t come equipped with a price tag. It doesn’t mean quantitative analysis can’t be incorporated but you have to use different systems.”

Gore urges pension funds to start asking corporations questions, saying it will “have a profound effect” on the behaviour of companies.

“Pension funds can be the most important driver of the new phenomenon, by asking questions, and engagement. When pension funds are evaluating what to invest in, start asking questions, it will have a profound effect,” he says.

“But I want to repeat a central point. This is not social engineering or getting pension funds to take on social policy or government reform. But you should do it because it improves your performance, and matches your vision with a wider spectrum of what reality really is.”

Five recommendations of Generation Investment Management’s Sustainable Capitalism white paper

  1. Identify and incorporate risks from stranded assets
  2. Mandate integrated reporting
  3. End the default practice of issuing quarterly earnings guidance
  4. Align compensation structures with long term sustainable performance
  5. Encourage long term investing with loyalty driven securities

If investors were to focus on one aspect of the five recommendations, Blood says that identifying and incorporating risks of stranded assets would be the first choice.

“The most relative commercial issue in portfolios is to mobilise capital to low carbon,” Blood says.

The second would be around incentive structures.

“If incentive structures are short term and rewards are reinforced by short term performance then the ability to see the long term is damaged,” Gore says. “I’ve only been in the asset management business for 12 years but I have learnt that people will do what you pay them to do.”

Photo: Kasey Baker/Wikimedia Commons

© Copyright: Whole articles from this website and newsletter cannot be reproduced without permission from the editor. If you wish to publish introductions to any article please ensure that it links to original content site www.top1000funds.com.au, and that it shows clear attribution to Top1000funds.com, plus author name and date. Failure to abide by this request will be considered a breach of copyright and legal action will be taken.

 
  • Filter:
  • News

    Intelligence on up to the minute items from around the globe

  • Investor Profile

    Behind the scenes summary of large institutional investors’ investment strategy and future plans

  • In Conversation

    Candid conversation with the leading investment experts

  • Analysis

    An in-depth examination of the latest investment trends and ideas

  • Insider

    An editorial perspective on what affects the people and processes in this industry

  • Research

    Cutting edge academic and practitioner insight

How to hedge long-term inflation-linked liabilities without inflation-linked instruments

  • by
  • November 26, 2014

Given the capacity constraints on local inflation-linked bond markets, what are other options for hedging ... [more]

Breaking down emerging markets active returns

New research by MSCI shows a rare insight into whether the factor phenomenon, driving development ... [more]

Invert the business model to focus on members: Ambachtsheer

There is a lot more work to do in raising the quality of governance of ... [more]

SSgA focuses on innovation not assets

For Scott Powers, president and chief executive of State Street Global Advisors, assets under management ... [more]

Pension funds put pressure on G20 tax reform

Pension funds are becoming vocal ahead of the G20 leaders summit next week, reiterating the ... [more]

How factor investing also works for corporate bonds

Two Robeco researchers have become the first to analyze the effect that factor premiums can ... [more]

Concerns over private equity leave pension funds wary

Institutional investors are clearly attracted to private equity, but remain wary of the sector for ... [more]

All aboard the change express as Railpen leaves the station

At the end of a corporate review process that lasted eight months, involved 23 meetings ... [more]

Using a ‘foreign language shield’ to improve investment decision making

Introducing a “foreign language shield” into a decision-making process is a proven way of making ... [more]