ANALYSIS

The end of beauty contest active management?

Designing and implementing concentrated, long-horizon investment mandates would support longer term thinking, align pension organisation’s goals with its stakeholders, and reduce transaction costs.

This was one of the recommendations of a two-day workshop in Toronto last month, attended by a delegation of 80 pension fund executives from around the globe.

Aimed at uncovering the meaning and application of a 2012 Generation Investment Management white paper, Sustainable Capitalism, the workshop was co-hosted by the Rotman International Centre for Pension Management and the Generation Foundation.

It specifically wanted the funds to explore the practical implementation of the white paper’s recommended action plans, which were:

  1. Identify and incorporate risks from stranded assets;
  2. Mandate integrated reporting;
  3. End the default practice of issuing quarterly earnings guidance;
  4. Align compensation structures with long-term sustainable performance; and
  5. Encourage long-term investing with loyalty-driven securities.

The participants were broken into small groups and asked to think about what micro actions their pension organisations might take internally, and what collective macro action they would join in a larger industry, national or international collaboration.

The participants recommended that their own organisations design and implement concentrated, long horizon investment mandates, and ensure that they have the necessary resources to successfully implement them.

They also said they wanted to develop a “model investment mandate” through an organisation like ICPM that could be widely shared and reported on by investors.

The participants, that included representatives from funds such as the Washington State Investment Board, Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, the Canadian Pension Plan Investment Board, PGGM and APG, thought that a model mandate would force the development of new performance measures and incentive compensation schemes and challenge the dysfunctional inertia that continues to exist in many pension organisations.

Commenting on the investor recommendations Keith Ambachtsheer, director of Rotman ICPM and Rob Bauer, associate director of Rotman ICPM programs, said such mandates would be a radical departure from the traditional Keynesian “beauty contest” style of active management, and also from the broadly-diversified “formula” of passive management.

The key concept, they said, was the broad adoption of “concentrated long-term investment mandates” that require investor engagement.

The funds agreed that they would commence and advocate the adoption of integrated reporting of their own organisation’s results and for assessing the long horizon prospects of investments.

They would also focus on yearly results in one-on-one meetings between investors and corporate management, in a bid to end the focus on short term earnings.

Ambachtsheer says the next step in the process, to facilitate change and to really have a profound effect in the bid to make sustainable capitalism mainstream, is collaboration.

“We need to take an activist approach to the conversations with a collaborative model. Investors as a group should make four or five choices about how to change behaviour and all get behind it,” he says.

ICPM has written papers in the past on successful models of collaboration concluding they need to have clarity, common interest, an executive function and a budget, and the ability to track success and adjust plans accordingly.

Ambachtsheer uses asset management incentive structures as an example of potential change via collaboration.

“If asset owners insisted on new structures then managers would do it because they wouldn’t have a job,” he says. “If they think in the short term they will get away with it they’ll do it, it’s easier, more exciting and they get feedback immediately. If enough of an investor base changes their expectations it will create demand.”

© Copyright: Whole articles from this website and newsletter cannot be reproduced without permission from the editor. If you wish to publish introductions to any article please ensure that it links to original content site www.top1000funds.com.au, and that it shows clear attribution to Top1000funds.com, plus author name and date. Failure to abide by this request will be considered a breach of copyright and legal action will be taken.

 
  • Filter:
  • News

    Intelligence on up to the minute items from around the globe

  • Investor Profile

    Behind the scenes summary of large institutional investors’ investment strategy and future plans

  • In Conversation

    Candid conversation with the leading investment experts

  • Analysis

    An in-depth examination of the latest investment trends and ideas

  • Insider

    An editorial perspective on what affects the people and processes in this industry

  • Research

    Cutting edge academic and practitioner insight

What, really, are your pension liabilities?

  • by
  • October 25, 2014

Liabilities in UK pension schemes are grossly under-estimated with the current valuation system not recognising ... [more]

Behind the long-horizon equities mandate at The Pensions Trust

How to implement long-term ideology is one of the enduring questions for investors. Unilever UK ... [more]

Future Fund focuses on finding the best people

Australia’s sovereign wealth fund, the A$101 billion Future Fund, has just upped the stakes in ... [more]

The cost of bad asset allocation

A study of 300 US pension funds by CEM Benchmarking reinforces the importance of asset ... [more]

Towards a new generation of pension funds in Australia

  • by
  • October 10, 2014

Numerous surveys suggest that Australians are not completely satisfied with superannuation as it exists today. ... [more]

The OECD’s plan for long-term investment

G20 financial ministers and central bank governors welcomed the findings of the G20/OECD roundtable on ... [more]

Why long-horizon investors should adopt factor-based asset allocation

Long-horizon investors can withstand macro-economic volatility and so should tilt towards strategies that are exposed ... [more]

The case for long-termism

Keith Ambachtsheer’s lead article in the Fall 2014 edition of the Rotman International Journal of ... [more]

Are your managers as active as you think they are?

Measuring how active managers actually are is a useful tool for investors. A metric called ... [more]